Environmental Myth-Busting: What Clinicians Really Need to Know

From backyard snakebites to jellyfish stings on summer vacations, environmental injuries have a way of showing up in our EDs and clinics. These cases often arrive wrapped in anxiety—and a few well-intentioned, not-so-helpful first-aid myths. Think: tourniquets for snakebites, vinegar for every jellyfish sting, or the assumption that someone with heat stroke has to look dry and flushed.

As clinicians, we need to cut through the myths and lean on evidence-informed practices that prioritize patient safety and clarity. Here are three common environmental misconceptions you’re likely to encounter, and what you should do instead.

1. Skip the Snakebite Shortcuts

Commercial suction kits. Electric shocks. The good old “cut and suck.” These snakebite strategies live on in pop culture (and in some first-aid kits) but they don’t actually help. Worse, they can make things more complicated by damaging tissue, introducing bacteria, or delaying care.

What works instead:

• ▪️Get the patient to a medical facility ASAP

  ▪️Identification of the snake, if possible (a photo is helpful, but bringing the snake to the hospital is not!)

• ▪️Watch for swelling, bruising, or rapid symptom progression

• ▪️Check labs for coagulopathy (CBC, DIC panel, coag studies)

• ▪️Call your friendly neighborhood toxicologist for help with antivenom decisions

• ▪️Repeat physical exams to track systemic effects

•  

  2. Jellyfish Stings: Think Salt

• It’s one of the most well-known myths in environmental medicine: the idea that urinating on a jellyfish sting can relieve pain or neutralize venom. This advice, popularized by television and folklore, has no scientific basis and can make things worse.

  Here’s what helps:

  • ▪️Gently remove visible tentacles

  • ▪️Irrigate with salt water, never fresh water (which can trigger more venom release due to tonicity changes)

  • ▪️Provide appropriate pain relief

   

•  

• Treatment varies widely depending on the species, so clinicians in coastal regions should familiarize themselves with the local types of jellyfish. Some treatments (like vinegar) that are beneficial for some species may worsen the problem, and antivenom may be indicated in some species, like the box jellyfish, and toxicology consultation can be an invaluable partner when species identification is possible.

3. Sweating Doesn’t Rule Out Heat Stroke

One dangerous myth that persists in both lay and clinical circles is the idea that a sweating patient cannot have heat stroke. In reality, patients, particularly those with exertional heat stroke, may continue to sweat even as they develop life-threatening hyperthermia.

Key indicators of heat stroke:

• ▪️Elevated core temperature from environmental or exertional exposure

• ▪️Altered mental status (confusion, disorientation, agitation)

Cooling strategies:

• ▪️Ice water immersion is faster and more efficient when available

▪️Evaporative cooling (water spray + fan) is effective and widely accessible

If a patient presents with heat exposure and any central nervous system symptoms, they need emergency transfer and a full workup for possible end-organ damage.

Additional Quick Facts for Clinical Context

Drowning in salt vs. fresh water

There’s no meaningful electrolyte difference in standard drowning cases. That myth comes from outdated animal studies. The one outlier? The Dead Sea, where hypertonic fluid can actually mess with electrolytes.

Hypothermic cardiac arrest

The old adage holds: “You’re not dead until you’re warm and dead.” Profound hypothermia—especially in kids—can be neuroprotective. Unless there are obvious signs incompatible with life (like decapitation or massive trauma), keep going until they’re rewarmed to 32°C.

Environmental emergencies often arrive with a dose of drama, and maybe some misinformation. As clinicians, we have the opportunity to bring clarity, calm, and evidence to situations that are sometimes shaped more by pop culture than by science.

Whether you're working in a coastal clinic, a desert ER, or just seeing an uptick in heat-related visits this summer, remembering these principles can help you deliver grounded, effective care.